What Is the “Right to Fall” In a Nursing Home?
The “right to fall” is an informal ethical concept concerning nursing home resident autonomy, meaning that residents have the right to refuse help and move independently, even if this increases risk. However, the right to fall cannot excuse preventable injuries or shield nursing homes from legal action.
If your loved one’s fall resulted in serious injuries or death, a nursing home fall lawyer can investigate the circumstances, explain fall rights, and determine the nursing home’s liability depending on the specific circumstances.
What Is a Nursing Home Resident’s Legal Right to Fall?
No specific law explicitly gives a nursing home resident a right to fall. Rather, the concept is based on the Nursing Home Reform Act, established in 1987. This federal law governs nursing home standards and established the Nursing Home Resident’s Bill of Rights, which includes the right to dignity, respect, self-determination, and autonomy.
Residents of nursing homes, assisted living facilities, and other healthcare facilities are entitled to understand their fall risk and decide what risks they are willing to take regarding their own health. They may also refuse care, such as fall-prevention measures they believe are overly restrictive.
However, the Nursing Home Reform Act also gives residents the right to be free from abuse or neglect. This means that although a resident can refuse care, the nursing home must also protect them from negligent acts that may result in a fall or unsafe conditions that could increase their risk.
How Does Informed Risk-Taking Connect to Fall-Related Injuries?
Nursing homes must develop individualized care plans for each resident, including fall-prevention plans. Under 42 CFR 483.10, facilities must allow residents to see these care plans, which should explain the measures in place to prevent falls. If a resident decides not to follow the care plan after being informed of the potential consequences, they have made an informed decision to increase their risk.
Care facilities must document a resident’s informed choices about risk, but they may still be liable for nursing home injuries resulting from negligence or lack of supervision.
Why the Right to Fall Does Not Eliminate Nursing Home Liability
Just because a nursing home resident has the right to fall does not mean that the facility cannot be held liable for nursing home negligence. They must still create comprehensive care plans meant to reduce risk, perform fall risk assessments, and comply with federal regulations.
Nursing Home Care Planning and Fall Risk Assessments
The definition of a nursing home fall is an unintentional descent to the floor, ground, or a lower level, with or without injuries. Between 50% and 75% of nursing home residents fall annually, which is higher than the fall rate of older individuals living in the community.
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services require nursing homes to assess fall risk and offer appropriate interventions, such as mobility assistance or a wheelchair. Using bed rails requires an individualized assessment of their potential risks and benefits. The person may refuse them, but the facility must offer them or risk liability.
Federal Regulations for Fall Prevention Measures
Federal regulation 42 CFR Part 483 controls nursing home fall prevention. This statute requires facilities to create a safe environment free of environmental hazards and to assess fall risk factors for every resident so the person receives individualized fall prevention.
Under 42 CFR 483.12, nursing homes cannot use chemical or physical restraints to prevent falls, as this violates a nursing home resident’s right to be free from abuse or neglect. Excessive restrictions not only violate a resident’s rights, but also lead to psychological distress and physical decline.
Federal law also controls nursing home fall reporting requirements. Under 42 CFR 483.12(c), nursing homes must report allegations involving abuse or serious bodily injury within 2 hours, while other covered allegations must be reported within 24 hours. Nursing homes should also document falls, investigate their causes, and take appropriate measures to prevent future incidents. In 2025, the Office of Inspector General found that nursing homes failed to report 43% of falls involving major injuries and hospitalization among Medicare-enrolled residents in their required assessments.
Nursing homes must also undergo regular compliance inspections. These are usually administered through the relevant state agency, such as the Illinois Department of Public Health or another governing body. Failure to do so can mean losing Medicare certification for negligence in fall prevention or reporting.

When a Nursing Home May Be Negligent for Fall Injuries
The right to fall does not eliminate a nursing home’s obligation to prioritize safety, including personalized care, safe premises, and adequate staffing to help residents when needed. Common scenarios that may suggest nursing home negligence can include:
- Inadequate Care Planning: Elderly nursing home residents at high risk of falls must be offered extra precautions that could protect them, even if they refuse the accommodations. For example, a resident with low vision may be fine during the day but need nightlights or a specific toileting schedule to prevent nighttime falls. Failure to offer this is a form of negligence, even if the person has a right to fall.
- Inadequate Monitoring: Regular monitoring can reduce fall risks. Staff members should check on residents every 15 to 30 minutes in case they need something, such as help with toileting or retrieving items. A resident may try to fetch things or go to the bathroom alone if they can’t find someone to help them, increasing fall risk.
- Understaffing: Around one-third of nursing home fall injuries occur among residents who cannot walk. While these residents still have the right to fall, a facility should ensure enough staff are available to provide mobility assistance, whether that means holding a walker steady while the person rises or walking them to the bathroom.
- Environmental Hazards: Environmental hazards contribute to 15% to 30% of nursing home falls. Wet floors, cluttered hallways, excessive decorations around doors, or broken lighting can make a facility negligent even if a person has refused fall-risk prevention measures.
- Delayed Medical Care or Lack of Reporting: Around 1 in 5 falls in nursing homes cause serious injuries, such as broken bones. These should be treated as medical emergencies and require immediate transfer to a hospital, but staff may delay treatment. Staff members may also fail to submit incident reports.
Evidence Used to Prove Facility Negligence After a Fall
Evidence that we may use during a nursing home fall investigation includes:
- Individualized care plans
- Incident reports
- Medication Administration Records (MARs)
- Medical records and transfer logs
- Nursing staff reports
- Witness testimony
- Nursing home staff records
- Surveillance footage, if available
- Facility communications
- Citation and inspection records
- Maintenance records
The goal is to understand what the resident’s care plan and federal regulations required the nursing home to provide compared to what was actually offered. We may also consult with expert witnesses, such as elder care professionals and life care planners, to provide better context around how the nursing home failed to uphold its duty of care to the injured person.
Why Repeated or Serious Falls May Require a Legal Review
A fall with severe injuries may suggest the facility did not do enough to protect elderly residents, even if the person refused certain interventions. This is especially true if multiple nursing home residents suffered preventable falls despite having different care plans and levels of disability.
A nursing home neglect lawyer can review all circumstances surrounding the fall, including the facility layout, staffing levels, and staff response times. We can also examine the facility’s records to determine whether other residents experienced falls and under what circumstances.
This evidence can help negotiate nursing home fall settlements. Potential damages that can be recovered include medical bills, rehabilitation costs, future medical needs, physical pain and suffering, and mental anguish. If the fall resulted in death, then families may receive compensation for funeral and burial expenses, loss of companionship, and grief.
Contact Us for a Free Consultation About Your Loved One’s Fall
If your loved one suffered a fall, a nursing home abuse lawyer from Nursing Home Law Center can investigate the circumstances surrounding the fall, review care plans, and identify liable parties. Our legal team offers free consultations and works on a contingency fee basis. Contact us today to learn more about your legal options after a nursing home fall.

