Search
Do highly rated nursing homes give families a false sense of security?
Yesterday I was contacted by the daughter of a nursing home patient who died after suffering a fall in the bathroom of a well-known– and highly rated– nursing home in Chicago.
After several minutes of discussion about her her father’s physical condition and her recollection of safeguards that were to be implemented by the facility to prevent falls, she then began to question if the facility really did anything wrong– in light of its fine reputation.
Sure, having a good reputation is an important thing for any business— nursing homes included– but as a patient or family member, it is important to remember that a facilities fine reputation in the past does not mean that the facility gets to automatically maintain that reputation in the future. Further, even the most highly regarded facilities are staffed by ordinary humans— who do make mistakes when it comes to patient care.
As a lawyer who sees incidents stemming from negligent care— at both –highly rated— as well as facilities that may not have such great track records, I always suggest to families that each incident should be reviewed independently of the nursing home or hospitals rating or reputation in the community as it really has little bearing on the incident at issue.
When medical mistakes are made at more esteemed facilities– nursing home and hospitals, I do see more of these facilities recognize the error for what it is and make and effort to evaluate meritorious claims with an eye towards resolution.
The bottom line is that while a nursing home’s reputation may be excellent, it should not be a deterrent when it comes to pursuing claims involving poor care– isolated incident or not.
Below is a list of Chicago-land nursing homes that deserve recognition for receiving a 5-star overall rating from Medicare.
CHICAGOLAND NURSING HOMES
5 STARS
Clare at Water Tower
55 East Pearson
Chicago, IL 60611
Little Sisters of the Poor
2325 North Lakewood Avenue
Chicago, IL 60614
Community Care
4314 South Wabash Avenue
Chicago, IL 60653
Belmont Nursing Home
1936 West Belmont Avenue
Chicago, IL 60657
Carlton at the Lake
725 West Montrose Avenue
Chicago, IL 60613
St. Paul’s House & Health Center
3800 North California Avenue
Chicago, IL 60618
Selfhelp Home of Chicago
908 West Argyle Street
Chicago, IL 60640
Bethesda Home & Retirement Center
2833 North Nordica Avenue
Chicago, IL 60634
Lincolnwood Place
7000 North McCormick Blvd.
Lincolnwood, IL 60645
Dobson Plaza
120 Dodge Avenue
Evanston, IL 60202
Gottlieb Memorial Hospital
701 West North Avenue
Melrose Park, IL 60160
The British Home
8700 West 31st Street
Brookfield, IL 60513
Norwood Crossing
6016 North Nina Avenue
Chicago, IL 60631
Resurrection Life Center
7370 West Talcott Avenue
Chicago, IL 60631
St. Benedict Nursing & Rehab
6930 West Touhy Avenue
Niles, IL 60714