Even though Ruby McDonough didn’t win her nursing home abuse lawsuit, the 63-year-old aphasia sufferer emerged from a Framingham, Mass. courtroom victorious.
“What’s important is the message that [McDonough] sends to predators,” said McDonough’s lawyer, Wendy Murphy. “You may think you can pick on a woman like Ruby, a person with aphasia, but it’s no longer true.”
McDonough suffers from a particular from of called “expressive aphasia,” which severely limits speaking and writing abilities. McDonough can only express herself with two or three words, and was trying to prove that she was sexually abusedat the Sudbury Pines Rehabilitation Center in 2009. McDonough claimed that a Ghanian worker named Kofi Agana had fondled her breasts and touched her between her legs.
According to the Metrowest Daily News, McDonough was able to point to Agana as her perpetrator, and was able to demonstrate on her own body where she’d been touched. Yet some of the answers she gave were conflicting, and she often had difficulty understanding questions. In the end, with what seemed like an air of regret, the judge ruled there wasn’t enough evidence to pin Agana as the assailant.
“The one thing we have to accommodate is the burden of proof,” said Judge Robert Greco. “Something happened in that nursing home, but I don’t know what happened, where it happened, or who exactly did it…Something unfair may have happened to (McDonough), but life can be unfair sometimes. I can’t find a finding of anything other than not guilty.”
Despite the ruling, the federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement has ordered Agana deported back to Ghana.
Mentally Disabled Patients Are Easy Targets for Abuse in Institutional Settings January 21, 2010 Nursing Homes Abuse Blog
‘Aphasia’ Educates on Communication Disorder September 25, 2011 ABC News Chicago
Learning to Speak All Over Again January 11, 2009 CBS Evening News