New York Nursing Home Bed Sore Case Valuation

Bed Sore in Nursing HomesAcross New York and across the country even, nursing homes and their residents are really just waking up to the threat and risk of bed sores. Some people also call them decubitus ulcers or pressure sores but they mean the same thing.

Generally, residents get them from too much pressure or friction from sitting too long without moving or rubbing materials over the skin. It might seem not that serious but they can be fatal.

What happens is that the surface of the skin will blister then tear and infections seep down into the bone and surrounding tissue. It’s when the infection takes hold and spreads that the sore can go from just a blister to a life-threatening condition.

Here are some New York nursing home lawsuits that highlight bed sores.

$500,000 NURSING HOME VERDICT:

Kings County, New York nursing home bed sore case.

The plaintiff in this lawsuit was a man in his middle seventies. He was transferred to the nursing home at the center of this dispute only for a few weeks. He was supposed to remain there until his schedule treatments were to begin at a nearby hospital.

However, while at the facility, he developed bed sores that quickly worsened and threatened his health. He had to be taken to the hospital earlier than expected and died shortly after they became infected.

Lawyers for the man’s estate sued the nursing facility on statutory, negligence, and wrongful death grounds. They argued that its deficient care was the reason he developed bed sores and died. They pointed to a list of errors including a failure to create an individualized plan to prevent bed sores on his body, a failure to turn him over regularly or monitor his position (even while they erroneously said they were), and a failure to give him the required nutrients and water.

The defendant nursing home denied most of these charges except the statutory failure to keep him free from bed sores. Accordingly, the jury didn’t find it hard to render a verdict in the man’s favor and awarded his estate $500,000.

Here were some strengths in the plaintiffs’ case:

  • New York has a very resident-friendly statute that basically awards plaintiffs compensation anytime they develop bed sores at a nursing home and the plaintiffs relied heavily on this law.
  • The fact that he developed multiple health complications only at the nursing home lent further credence to the idea that it was negligence.
  • The man died shortly after the bed sores became infected and this made his case even stronger as it now was also a wrongful death action.

$1,250,000 NURSING HOME VERDICT:

Kings County, New York nursing home bed sore case.

This lawsuit was filed after a man died in the care of a nursing facility. He had been staying at the home for an extended period of time because he was very old and could not take care of himself. The nursing home was not helpful.

Over a period of time, he developed bed sores on his foot, back, and buttocks. Due to the fact that staff were not regularly changing his adult diaper, some of these sores became infected and he developed sepsis and died.

Once his representatives learned of this development, they brought suit against the nursing home for negligence and wrongful death. In their complaint, they alleged that the defendant nursing home did not properly turn him over, clean him, or otherwise care for him.

They stated that because of this negligent service, he grew bed sores, bed sores he already had got worse, he gained infections, and he died. They sought financial and punitive damages for all these injuries.

The defendant replied to all of these charges in its reply. It said that it did nothing wrong and in no way contributed to his injuries or death. The matter went to trial where the jury awarded the man’s family $1,250,000.

Here are some points that weighed in the plaintiffs’ favor:

  • The fact that the decedent developed sores and died on the nursing home’s watch would have suggested negligence and causation under New York’s public health laws. This presumption would have been hard to rebut.
  • The majority of the verdict was given for lost services in order to compensate the surviving members of the victim’s family.

$450,000 NURSING HOME SETTLEMENT:

Kings County, New York nursing home bed sore case.

The lawyers in this nursing home case represented a deceased man who died shortly after being transferred out of a nursing home. In October of that year, the nursing home staff determined that he had bed sores on his heels and lower spine. They were stage four, necrotic, and infected. Just one month later, they descended into a gangrenous state and he needed to be transferred to a nearby hospital.

To correct the problem, doctors needed to perform an amputation on the man’s leg but it proved to be of no avail. He died just a few weeks later. His representatives brought a cause of action against the nursing home for negligence and wrongful death.

They charged that the facility committed a number of errors and that all of them combined to cause the man’s death.

As much as the defendant disagreed, it still agreed to settle and the man’s estate received $450,000.

Here’s a few points about why it might’ve gotten that amount:

  • The nursing home had no record of when it repositioned him and this undercut its claim that it provided him with appropriate care.
  • The man’s health declined rapidly once the bed sore took hold and this weakened the facility’s argument that the man’s other health conditions were to blame.

$1,025,000 NURSING HOME VERDICT:

Erie County, New York nursing home bed sore case.

This nursing home verdict was rendered after a female resident sustained a number of injuries during her stay her. On one particular day, staff at the facility assisted her into the restroom and then left her for no reason.

Subsequently, she fell down and severely injured herself. After receiving care at a nearby hospital, she was brought back to the same nursing home.

However, things didn’t get any better because she developed bed sores on her feet and back. They eventually became infected. After consulting with her lawyers about these events, she chose to bring a lawsuit against the nursing home for the various injuries, costs, and damages that its care imparted onto her.

Her complaint asked for nearly thirty million dollars in compensation for compensatory and punitive recovery.

The defendant disagreed with this amount as well as with the fact that it was responsible at all for her harms.

However, the jury bought the plaintiff’s story to the tune of $1,025,000 potentially for these reasons:

  • It is almost per se negligence in New York when residents develop bed sores in nursing homes.
  • The woman was severely handicapped from the fall in the restroom and disfigured due to the treatments for her bed sores.

$270,000 NURSING HOME VERDICT:

Richmond County, New York nursing home bed sore case.

The nursing home victim at the center of this dispute was a 70-year-old veteran. One morning he was found on the floor of his room. Apparently, he fell down the previous day and could not get up on his own. The nursing home staff had not noticed that he was prone and helpless.

The incident left him with a number of injuries and he was taken to the hospital not far from the facility. After being admitted for emergency care, doctors soon noticed that he had developed bed sores across his lower back and spine.

He was also experiencing symptoms of obesity, diabetes, and other problems. Regarding the sores, doctors prescribed a course of debridement, medication, and dressing changes. Then they sent him back to the nursing home from which he came. However, he didn’t live very long after that.

His lawyers suggested the trauma and pain of these events led to his death. They sued the nursing home for negligence and alleged that it didn’t assess his condition, reposition his body, respond to doctor’s orders, or generally provide sufficient care.

The defendant nursing home denied these claims and suggested that the man’s pre-existing conditions were to blame. The jury was not convinced. It awarded the estate $300,000.

Here’s why the man’s estate got what it did in court:

  • The decedent was also given 10% of the blame for the events involved in this lawsuit and that lowered his award from $300,000 to $270,000.
  • The plaintiffs could clearly show that the facility ignored the doctor’s orders and that was used to prove that it was legally the cause of his injuries.

$150,000 NURSING HOME VERDICT:

Bronx, New York nursing home bed sore case.

The plaintiff in this nursing home case was the estate of a deceased 89-year-old woman. What transpired just prior to her death was the focus of this cause of action. One month before her passing, the nursing home staff where she was staying noticed that she had stage two bed sores.

Then, a few weeks later, they realized that they had progress to stage four. It was only then that she was taken to a hospital where doctors were able to perform debridement to take care of them.

She was then released and sent back to the nursing home but she didn’t get better. She had to be sent back to the hospital where she passed away shortly thereafter. Her representatives sued the nursing home.

They stated that the facility failed to adequately reposition her, monitor her, supply her with proper mattresses and equipment, or take action when they realized she had bed sores.

The defendant refused these contentions so the matter went to court. The jury declared that the defendant nursing home violated public health laws in negligently caring for the woman.

They awarded the estate $150,000 for the following damages:

  • Medical bills.
  • Pain and suffering while alive.
  • Funeral and burial expenses.
  • Attorney’s fees.

NEW YORK NURSING HOME BED SORE CASE TAKEAWAYS

New York lawsuits that deal with bed sores in nursing homes are some of the most complex affairs. That complexity can make it nearly impossible to understand what’s going on but these takeaways should help you better understand your incident and possible lawsuit:

  1. Some common problems that nursing homes have in the context of bed sores at trial are whether or not they conducted an initial assessment, developed a plan to prevent them, or spotted and treated them if they did develop.
  2. New York law puts most of the blame on nursing homes if residents develop bed sores for whatever reason that they developed them.
  3. Plaintiffs had the most success proving causation when they could point to a nursing home’s past citations for not preventing bed sores.
  4. Plaintiffs that developed sepsis or other infections tended to win at jury trials at a higher rate and recover larger settlements in bed sore cases.

DID YOUR FAMILY MEMBER GET A BED SORE WHILE STAYING AT A NEW YORK NURSING HOME?

Nursing Home Law News team works with victims suffering from bed sores. We have a long history helping them get the help and recovery that they need in order to move on from these serious injuries.

Also, if you have to go to court to get compensation, we can represent you on contingency so that you don’t have to pay a dime for our services unless you get an award or settlement that works for you. Just call us today so that we can put you on the path to recovery.

For information on laws and regulations applicable to New York nursing homes, look here.

If you are looking for information on a local nursing home or for a lawyer who has experience with nursing home negligence matters, please refer to links below:

Client Reviews

★★★★★
Jonathan did a great job helping my family navigate through a lengthy lawsuit involving my grandmother's death in a nursing home. Through every step of the case, Jonathan kept my family informed of the progression of the case. Although our case eventually settled at a mediation, I really was impressed at how well prepared Jonathan was to take the case to trial. Lisa
★★★★★
After I read Jonathan’s Nursing Home Blog, I decided to hire him to look into my wife’s treatment at a local nursing home. Jonathan did a great job explaining the process and the laws that apply to nursing homes. I immediately felt at ease and was glad to have him on my side. Though the lawsuit process was at times frustrating, Jonathan reassured me, particularly at my deposition. I really felt like Jonathan cared about my wife’s best interests, and I think that came across to the lawyers for the nursing home. Eric