Rapid Deterioration Of Nursing Home Patient Highlights Poor Care At An Illinois Facility

Poor Care At An Illinois FacilityAs an attorney who spends a good amount of time evaluating nursing home negligence cases, I am frequently asked, ‘what makes a case good?” Obviously, we are referring to a litigation context where the term ‘good’ is all relative– but there are several factors which make some nursing home injury cases more appealing to me in a litigation context.

Why some nursing home cases are ‘better’ than others

While we can literally write a treatise about what distinguishes ‘good’ v. ‘bad’ accident cases, in the nursing home setting I tend to give a strong preference to cases involving short-term rehabilitation. Or circumstances that arise after a patient spends just a few days or weeks at a facility.

Of course there are plenty of bad things that can happen to a patient regardless if a patient was at a facility for 24-hours, 24-days or 24-months. Certainly, I’m not giving a pass to a situation where a patient is harmed– but what makes some short-term injury cases more desirable for the perspective of a plaintiff’s attorney is that these nursing home accident cases very frequently involve a situation where staff members are not familiar with the patients needs to care plan set forth by their physician.  These unfamiliarity’s commonly play at least some part in episodes involving patient decline or even fatalities.

A before & after contrast resonates with jurors

Having litigated a number cases involving patient injury during a short-term admission, these cases tend to resonate well with a judge or jury as the concept of a patient literally walking into a facility only to be rushed to a hospital for serious complication the days and weeks following is usually more indicative of inferior care than a person who may have spent years at a facility before a problem developed.

I began to consider the recurring themes of short-term nursing home admissions and the accompanying problems when I read about a recently filed nursing home abuse lawsuit involving a facility in Southern Illinois. As reported in The Telegraph article “Nursing home sued over woman’s death,” the article discussed an all too familiar situation where just several weeks after their initial admission the patient is rushed to hospital for ensuing medical complications.  The nursing home lawsuit alleges that Eldercare of Alton and the patient’s treating physician, Dr. Rajnikant K. Patel were responsible for allowing the patient to develop a deadly infection that ultimately claimed the patient’s life.

In this case, the allegations of neglect were verified by the Illinois Department of Public Health during an investigation of the facility following the patient’s death where it was determined that “[b]ased on record review and interview, the facility neglected to assess, monitor and implement interventions for a decline in condition.”

The ‘decline’ in the patients condition necessitated an admission to nearby St. Anthony’s Hospital where the patient was treated for:

  • Septic shock
  • Multi-system failure
  • Metabolic encephalopathy
  • Myocardial infarction
  • Hypotension
  • Hypoclycemia
  • Severe urinary tract infection
  • Elevated Digoxin levels (blood thinner)

More than a coincidence? We’ll see.

Could the above conditions develop if the staff at Eldercare of Alton were following the patient’s care plan? Of course it’s possible, but if my experience is any indication of care provided in this case, my guess is that this is more than a mere coincidence?


One response to “Rapid Deterioration Of Nursing Home Patient Highlights Poor Care At An Illinois Facility”

  1. Linda Shafer says:

    Thank you for posting this.  I may contact you regarding my Mom’s death in what was supposed to be short term rehab after surgery from a broken hip.  She was due to come home within a few days when I got a call saying she’d been found unresponsive and had gone full code.  She could not be revived.  Her death has baffled me, has many bizarre twists and turns and is very complicated, so I may contact you with the details.  To my knowledge, there is still adequate time for legal action.  I have all her records.  A law firm I contacted held her records for a year with no action or evaluation, then suddenly made a snap decision that her case didn’t meet their criteria and sent everything back to me.  I now, after reading this account you wrote, question the law firm’s decision.  Thank you, sir.  You’re doing a great service.  God bless you.

Justia Lawyer Rating for Jonathan Rosenfeld

Client Reviews

Jonathan did a great job helping my family navigate through a lengthy lawsuit involving my grandmother's death in a nursing home. Through every step of the case, Jonathan kept my family informed of the progression of the case. Although our case eventually settled at a mediation, I really was impressed at how well prepared Jonathan was to take the case to trial. Lisa
After I read Jonathan’s Nursing Home Blog, I decided to hire him to look into my wife’s treatment at a local nursing home. Jonathan did a great job explaining the process and the laws that apply to nursing homes. I immediately felt at ease and was glad to have him on my side. Though the lawsuit process was at times frustrating, Jonathan reassured me, particularly at my deposition. I really felt like Jonathan cared about my wife’s best interests, and I think that came across to the lawyers for the nursing home. Eric