A Legal Victory For Nursing Home Residents. State Laws Can Supersede Federal Arbitration Act

Picture-29Some court decisions leave lots of room for future generations of law school classes to debate the subtleties of the Judge’s wording.  Yet, other times the the court’s action–without rendering an opinion– can have equally powerful results. What could I possibly be inarticulately blabbering about?

June 1st marked the deadline by which the U.S. Supreme Court could grant review of an Illinois Appellate Court decision nullifying nursing home arbitration arbitration agreements. Instead, the court decided to leave the Appellate decision untouched– in essence giving its stamp of approval to a holding striking an appellate court decision that invalidated mandatory arbitration agreements in nursing home negligence cases.

In Sue Carter v. SSC Odin Operating Company, LLC, (885 N.E. 2d 1204, 319 Ill.Dec. 524 (2008), the daughter of a nursing home resident brought a wrongful death and survival cause of action under the Illinois Nursing Home Care Act against the nursing home where her mother was a resident.  Despite the fact that Ms. Carter executed a ‘Health Care Arbitration Agreement’ on her mothers behalf when she admitted her mother to the facility, the Appellate Court ruled that state law preserved her right to a jury trial.

The nursing home operator appealed the Appellate Court decision, claiming the mandatory arbitration clause, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act, should overrule any state law as the federal legislation should take precedent.

Consequently, nursing home arbitration agreements in Illinois will likely be a thing of the past. Perhaps, this action by the court will dissuade other states from enforcing similar agreements.

Read more about this important case preserving nursing home resident rights here.

Nursing Homes Abuse Blog Posts On Arbitration Agreements

The Invalidity Of Nursing Home Arbitration Clauses

Are Trials Really That Important?

Michigan Court Strikes Nursing Home ‘Arbitration Clause’ And Allows Wrongful Death Case To Proceed In Court

AARP Joins Fight To Preserve Right To Jury Trial

Client Reviews

★★★★★
Jonathan did a great job helping my family navigate through a lengthy lawsuit involving my grandmother's death in a nursing home. Through every step of the case, Jonathan kept my family informed of the progression of the case. Although our case eventually settled at a mediation, I really was impressed at how well prepared Jonathan was to take the case to trial. Lisa
★★★★★
After I read Jonathan’s Nursing Home Blog, I decided to hire him to look into my wife’s treatment at a local nursing home. Jonathan did a great job explaining the process and the laws that apply to nursing homes. I immediately felt at ease and was glad to have him on my side. Though the lawsuit process was at times frustrating, Jonathan reassured me, particularly at my deposition. I really felt like Jonathan cared about my wife’s best interests, and I think that came across to the lawyers for the nursing home. Eric