Use Of Restraints Amongst Nursing Home Patients Has Been Reduced More Than 50% Over The Last Decade. Is It Enough?

Screen-shot-2010-07-23-at-2_03_44-PM2When you consider forms of cruel treatment, maybe you consider beds of nails or solitary confinement? However, another form of cruel treatment— the use of restraints, is commonly used with innocent nursing home patients. At some facilities, patient restraints are a commonly used tool used by facilities in lieu of providing actual hands-on patient care by facility staff.

In the past, nursing homes used physical restraints such as: bed rails, lap belts, vests, wrist ties and special chairs to assist them in literally controlling their patients.  In addition to de-humanizing patients, the use of restraints was attributed to rapid physical deterioration and increased rates of patient injury.

In response the the poor publicity and family outrage, many skilled nursing facilities have made great efforts to reduce use of restraints.  The reduction in restraint usage was recently discussed in an article by Megan Brooks on Medscape.

Ms. Brook’s article analyzed data from a News and Numbers report from the Agency for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety (AHRQ), which was part of a 2009 National Healthcare Disparities Report.  In short the reduction in use of restraints seems promising– from 1999 to 2007, the number of nursing home patients who were restrained dropped more than 50%.

By most estimates, just 5% of nursing home patients are restrained by facilities. Restraint usage varies significantly based on the following factors such as ethnicity, age and sex.

Certainly this is promising news for nursing home patients in general.  However, the data contained in the AHRQ report does not contain enough specifics regarding nursing home patient demographics to assess if restraints are being improperly utilized.

To restrain or not?

This really is a very difficult question to answer and the answer varies significantly amongst experts.  I feel restraints may be justified when the patient is at risk for harming themselves or others.

In my experience, I have witnessed facilities slow to utilize restraints— even after repeated episodes of falls.  In one of my cases, the facility refused to restrain a patient despite fourteen reported falls (many with associated injuries) at the facility. Unfortunately, the patient’s fifteenth fall resulted in a head injury which ultimately cost the patient her life.  In the course of litigation, I asked the director of nursing why the patient was not restrained, she advised that the facility was a ‘no restraint facility’.

In this case, I think there certainly is a very strong argument that I can (and will make) that with a no restraint policy, the facility was not properly equipped to care for this patient due to her extensive history of falls.

In another restraint case I worked on, a patient was seriously injured when she was left unattended in her geri-chair with an improperly placed lap belt.  Apparently, the belt was too loose and when the woman slipped down in her chair, she became entangled and choked.  Again, in the course of litigation, the facility disclosed that lap belts were used on all patients — regardless of their physical abilities.

Certainly, regardless of a facilities restraint usage policy, it is up to the facility adequately supervise patients to ensure the usage / non-usage of restraints doesn’t interfere with the patients well being. Further, this is an important issue for families to discuss and know where the facility caring for their loved ones stands on this issue.

Related Nursing Homes Abuse Blog Entries:

Many Nursing Homes & Assisted Living Facilities Continue To Threaten The Safety Of Their Patients With The Use Of Bed Rails In Their Facilities

Warnings Do Little To Prevent Bed Rail Entrapment 

Bedrail Entrapment

Can a nursing home tie my dad to a wheelchair if he has had episodes of wandering around the facility?


0 responses to “Use Of Restraints Amongst Nursing Home Patients Has Been Reduced More Than 50% Over The Last Decade. Is It Enough?”

  1. PJK says:

    Thank you.  I’m from Australia and I wish we had someone like you.  My mother is paralysed down one side of her body.  6 falls.  Geriatrician wrote recommending padded rails as it was too dangerous for her to sustain another fall.  Nursing home said it was a facility decision – not a medical decision.  Rails were restraints and they didn’t believe in restraints.  The stroke restrained he in my opinion.  The rails just kept her safe while she slept.  One day after a massive egg-sized lump on her forehead – no one knew how it had happened.  Called in aged Care Complaints.  They said the nursing home told them, when they investigated complaint, that a mattress was kept in the wardrobe to place next to the bed.  If they had bothered to open the wardrobe, they would have seen that it was a lie. Wardrobe too small to fit a mattress and when one eventually turned up 3 days later, it was never stored in the wardrobe.  My mother then had to wear hip protectors.  Uncomfortable and hot during a summer with some of the highest temperatures we’d experienced.  Unable to have a table over the bed with a drink as mattress in the way.  Had to visit three times a day to maintain hydration.  One day she had no voice.  She had fallen out of bed and laid there all night crying out for help.  No one helped until morning staff came in because apparently, here you can pay staff to sleep over night.  My mother is a high care resident.  

    When we wanted to move my mother – all hell broke out.  They tried every trick possible to keep her.  They told me that if I moved her she would die.  Her organs were shutting down and I had to let her go.  Two years later and my mother is doing extremely well and is happy in a very good nursing home.  More staff for the 16 residents than we ever saw for the 60 residents.  Very hard though to find a good one until you’re more experienced.

Justia Lawyer Rating for Jonathan Rosenfeld

Client Reviews

Jonathan did a great job helping my family navigate through a lengthy lawsuit involving my grandmother's death in a nursing home. Through every step of the case, Jonathan kept my family informed of the progression of the case. Although our case eventually settled at a mediation, I really was impressed at how well prepared Jonathan was to take the case to trial. Lisa
After I read Jonathan’s Nursing Home Blog, I decided to hire him to look into my wife’s treatment at a local nursing home. Jonathan did a great job explaining the process and the laws that apply to nursing homes. I immediately felt at ease and was glad to have him on my side. Though the lawsuit process was at times frustrating, Jonathan reassured me, particularly at my deposition. I really felt like Jonathan cared about my wife’s best interests, and I think that came across to the lawyers for the nursing home. Eric