New Mexico Nursing Home Inadequate Care Settlements & Verdicts (Case Valuation)

New Mexico Nursing Home Medication Error SettlementsAs more people decide that they need to enter a nursing home, facilities are pushed to capacity and exhaustion (of both personnel and resources). While it shouldn’t be the case in the best circumstances, it normally is the case in reality that we see a falloff in care.

Medications get missed. Treatments are forgotten. Residents are neglected.

However, the added pressure homes have is no excuse for inadequately caring for nursing residents because it’s exactly why they were admitted in the first place.

In the next few pages, we summarize some New Mexico nursing home verdicts and settlements involving medication errors. See if they might resemble your situation.

$54,000,000 Nursing Home Verdict

Bernalillo, New Mexico nursing home inadequate care case.

This nursing home lawsuit was brought on behalf of a seventy-eight year old woman who died in a New Mexico nursing home. Her lawyers argued that the home’s negligence caused her death. Specifically, the lawsuit alleged that facility staff was aware that the woman was suffering from internal bleeding but didn’t take action.

Then, when she did die, they erroneously gave her a shot to supposedly help her then falsified information to make it look like she had passed away under different circumstances. To add insult to injury, the suit stated that the staff also lied to the woman’s family about the incident and left her bloody clothing and sheets out in the open for several hours after the death.

The defendant nursing home denied that it was at fault and contended that she would have passed away anyways. However, it couldn’t point to anything to excuse its failures in the last few days of her life.

This might have been the reason why the jury was moved to award the family an extraordinary verdict figure of $54,000,000-$4,000,000 for compensatory damages and $50,000,000 for punitive damages.

Here are some things to note about this figure:

  • Punitive damages normally only exceeds compensatory damages by about two or three times so this award is well outside the New Mexico nursing home verdict average.
  • The compensatory damages amount was almost twenty times more than what they asked for which shows another example of the jury’s power to render verdicts beyond prediction.

$10,345,000 Nursing Home Verdict

San Miguel, New Mexico nursing home inadequate care case.

The size of this nursing home verdict was shocking especially considering the man died from unrelated caused before he even got it.

How did he obtain it?

Well, he was admitted to a nursing home following treatment related to a hip replacement procedure.

Things only got worse from there. Instead of getting better, his condition deteriorated significantly: he developed bed sores, they became infected, and he suffered from extraordinary malnutrition.

What made the chain of events so striking was that he was only fifty-five and in relatively good health prior to staying at the facility. After this course of events, he was completely immobile, had serious stage four bed sores, and was experiencing mental grief.

He sued the nursing home for negligence and maintained that its deficient care led to all of his health problems. He sought compensation for costs including medical bills, physical suffering, mental suffering, disability, and disfigurement.

However, the defendant clung to the idea that it did nothing wrong and served the resident with the level of care that he deserved. The jury disagreed.

They gave him $10,345,000 in recovery for the following damages:

  • $95,000 for medical bills;
  • $500,000 for pain and suffering; and
  • $9,750,000 for punitive damages.

$500,000 Nursing Home Settlement

New Mexico nursing home inadequate care case.

This case involved a rather unfortunate incident. The victim was an eighty-one-year-old woman who had dementia and a number of other debilitating conditions. She required supervision at all hours of the day. Unfortunately, on one occasion, that was not what she received.

On an early morning, nursing home staff found her lying on the floor of her room. It turns out that she had been there by herself for several hours. In fact, she broke her leg in the fall and couldn’t get up. Things got worse though when they realized that she hadn’t received her medicine for over two years prior to the incident.

She had to be taken to the hospital for treatment and stayed there for several weeks in recovery. Once she was better, she filed a lawsuit against the nursing home for negligence.

Her argument alleged that the facility’s negligent care and supervision led to her injuries and eventual disability.

Not long after the suit was brought to court, both sides settled for $500,000 and here are some things that explain that figure:

  • The woman was blatantly neglected for over eight hours and the plaintiffs could easily demonstrate her condition was worsened by that fact.
  • The injuries left the woman with significant disability and reduced quality of life.
  • The woman sustained costs because of the incident in the tens of thousands of dollars for emergency care and long-term rehabilitative treatment.

$150,000 Nursing Home Settlement

New Mexico nursing home inadequate care case.

This was an inadequate care lawsuit that rested primarily on neglect. What happened was the plaintiff was an elderly gentleman and veteran that had strict dietary and prescription needs.

He was suffering from chronic heart issues, diabetes, and other problems. Over the course of several months, he claimed that he did not regularly receive medication, adequate food or water, and other critical items and attention.

In his opinion, the result of all this neglect and inadequate service was a worsening of his already poor health as well as a lost chance at survival (the man died from unrelated reasons not long after the lawsuit was filed).

His complaint sought damages for costs, expenses, pain, suffering, lost chance, and wrongful death. The defendant plainly objected to all of these claims and replied that it gave him everything he need to live a healthy life but his pre-existing conditions didn’t all it.

However, preferring the certainty of settlement over the mystery of a jury trial, it still offered to settle and the estate accepted for $150,000.

Here are some key points about this settlement:

  • It’s several hundred thousand dollars lower than the average for wrongful death cases in New Mexico.
  • There was no citation for deficient care from the state.
  • Records were conflicted as to whether or not the facility had books and records to evidence it treated him properly.

$300,000 Nursing Home Settlement

New Mexico nursing home inadequate care case.

This case was more of a complication than one specific event. Over the course of several months, an eighty-two-year-old female nursing home resident didn’t receive significant water or hygiene treatment.

As a result, she suffered from severe dehydration which combined infections that developed due to lack of cleaning to nearly take her life. When the nursing home staff realized the problem, they immediately sent her to the hospital for care.

However, she had to stay there for several and was never the same again because of its effects. She sued the nursing facility for negligence and claimed damages for medical bills, pain, and long-term suffering as well as lower life quality.

The defendant home objected to the idea that it was at fault and countered that any ill effects she experienced were a result of her own condition and had nothing to do with them.

Yet, not long after this reply was filed, it still sought to settle and she got $300,000 most likely for these reasons:

  • The state came in and cited the home for repeated instances of neglect with respect to this patient.
  • The plaintiff claimed over $50,000 in direct costs from this affair.
  • The trial that was about to ensue would have taken at least one year and several hundred thousand dollars to litigate in court.

$100,000 Nursing Home Settlement

New Mexico nursing home inadequate care case.

This case might seem indifferent or commonplace but it’s indicative of common problems and accidents in New Mexico nursing homes so it’s worth reviewing. The victim was a resident in his early nineties. At the time of the accident, he was struggling with Alzheimer’s disease as well as other serious health issues.

On the day of the incident, he was walking around the facility by himself and found his way to actually exit the premises. When he tried getting back in, the door was locked and he banged on it to be let in but couldn’t get entry.

Then, he fell down. By the time that staff members finally found him, he had broken several bones and needed to be taken to the doctors. There the physicians treated him and put him in recovery. After a few months, he decided to sue the nursing home.

His lawsuit claimed that the facility negligently supervised him and that the inadequate care led to his injuries. It sought damages for his pain, costs, and suffering.

The defendant didn’t let the dispute progress very far before offering to settle for $100,000.

Here is why that number might seem appropriate:

  • His expenses were roughly a third of that amount so it breaks down closely to the New Mexico average in terms of the tangible-intangible damages ratio.
  • The man didn’t suffer any long-term disability or disfigurement from the accident-just a few broken bones that would heal in time.

New Mexico Nursing Home Inadequate Care & Medication Error Case Takeaways

Of all the things that nursing homes are supposed to give their residents, the most fundamental is a basic level of care and service. Yet, as seen from the above cases, that is not always what they get.

Keep in mind these takeaways if you were hurt because of a home’s inadequate care, such as a medical error:

  • See how the nursing home’s promises (in the form of the contracts, policies, and procedures) compare to its performance and record of performance.
  • If other residents have sued the nursing home in the past for similar or the exact same type of incident, then this might make your case stronger in court or settlement negotiations.
  • See if the nursing home ignored your doctors’ or nurses’ instructions and if this had any impact on your condition.
  • See when the nursing home figured out that you were injured and what they did about it once they knew because any delay might bode well for you in trial.
  • The extent to which you can make your pre-existing conditions irrelevant will directly improve your prospects in court.

Were You Injured due to a New Mexico Nursing Home’s Negligence?

Attorneys at Nursing Home Law News work with nursing home negligence victims to see if their facility’s conduct was to blame for their injuries. If it was, then we help them get all of the compensation they deserve under the law in New Mexico.

Plus, we won’t charge if you’re not happy with what we get you. Don’t wait though because you might miss your chance to recover. Call our offices today!

If you would like to know more about nursing home law in New Mexico, please read the following pages:

  • New Mexico Nursing Home Fall Cases
  • New Mexico Nursing Home Bed Sore Cases
  • New Mexico Nursing Home Abuse Cases
  • New Mexico Nursing Home Medical Error Cases

For information on the laws and regulations applicable to New Mexico nursing homes, look here.

Look at the links below for information and attorneys in local areas:

Client Reviews

Jonathan did a great job helping my family navigate through a lengthy lawsuit involving my grandmother's death in a nursing home. Through every step of the case, Jonathan kept my family informed of the progression of the case. Although our case eventually settled at a mediation, I really was impressed at how well prepared Jonathan was to take the case to trial. Lisa
After I read Jonathan’s Nursing Home Blog, I decided to hire him to look into my wife’s treatment at a local nursing home. Jonathan did a great job explaining the process and the laws that apply to nursing homes. I immediately felt at ease and was glad to have him on my side. Though the lawsuit process was at times frustrating, Jonathan reassured me, particularly at my deposition. I really felt like Jonathan cared about my wife’s best interests, and I think that came across to the lawyers for the nursing home. Eric