Michigan Nursing Home Abuse Case Settlements & Verdicts (Case Valuation)

Michigan Nursing Home Abuse Case ValuationAbuse is one of the most serious categories of incident types in nursing home lawsuits. It is common too because the field is so broad: physical, mental, emotional, sexual, and even financial.

It encompasses so many things but they all violate the same principle: the feeling of safety and security that each and every resident deserves. To show you the nature of the problem affecting nursing home patients, we have summarized some nursing home verdicts and nursing home settlements below.

They deal with abuse. If you have been abused in a Michigan nursing home, then give the nursing home abuse lawyers from our offices a call. We can make sure you get help and safety.

$150,000 Nursing Home Settlement

Wayne County, Michigan nursing home abuse case.

The plaintiff in this Michigan nursing home dispute was an elderly gentleman. He had limited range and mobility but could walk around the premises without the assistance of a wheelchair. On one day, another resident of the facility attacked him while he was moving about the grounds.

The reason for the assault was unknown but the consequences were quite obvious. He sustained facial lacerations, broken bones, and other bodily injuries.

He had to spend some time in the hospital and follow up with certain rehabilitative specialists. Once he was a bit better, he decided to bring a lawsuit against the nursing home and the man that assaulted him. As against the nursing home, he alleged that it failed to provide enough support to ensure proper supervision, that it failed to warn residents of the aggressor’s behavior, and that it failed to stop the man from attacking him.

The defendant facility denied that it was negligent or that it could be held responsible for the intentional torts of a third-party resident.

However, preferring the known to the unknown, it sought the confines of a predictable settlement over the risks of an unpredictable jury.

The plaintiff ended up getting $150,000 from the institution and that money went toward the following items:

  • Approximately $80,000 went to the plaintiff;
  • About $20,000 went to satisfy a Medicare lien; and
  • The rest went towards court costs and attorney’s fees.

$240,000 Nursing Home Verdict

Macomb County, Michigan nursing home abuse case.

This case was unique because it involved a husband and wife who both lived at the same nursing home where the events took place. The lawsuit was brought by the husband but it involved an incident that occurred to the woman.

He claimed that facility staff strapped her down and physically and sexually abused her. He stated that she suffered various injuries from the traumatic event including skin lacerations, vagina tear, and severe emotional distress. In fact, the husband claimed that she even died because of what happened.

The lawsuit said that the rape and attack was more than she could take and forced her to have a heart attack and pass away. The cause of action targeted the nursing home as well as the employees. It sought recovery on multiple theories including negligence, wrongful death, and even breach of contract.

It cited the defendants with specific failures like intentional torts such as battery, negligent training, negligent supervision, and lack of sufficient care. The defendant nursing home responded that it shouldn’t be held culpable for the intentional torts of its employees because they are outside the scope of employment.

This may have explained why the only issue remaining once the matter got to court was breach of contract.

On that point, the jury found for the plaintiff and awarded him $240,000. Here are some facts that highlight this nursing home verdict:

  • The plaintiff did settle out of court with the employee-defendant that actually attacked his wife;
  • This is almost more than double the median award for nursing home contract claims; and
  • It is nearly ten times what he claimed in expenses.

$200,000 Nursing Home Verdict

Wayne County, Michigan nursing home abuse case.

The resident in the middle of this nursing home storm was just sixteen years old. He was living there because he had disabilities since birth including hearing loss. On more than one occasion, he claimed that nursing home employees and other third-parties abused him and physically constrained him.

One particular occasion was rather disturbing. He alleged in his Michigan nursing home lawsuit that a facility staff member took him and threw him against a refrigerator.

He was severely injured because of it and even suffered a complete loss of hearing in one of his ears. After consulting with his parents and lawyers following the event, he decided to bring a lawsuit against the nursing home.

He alleged that it was responsible for its employees because it deficiently screened, trained, and supervised them. The defendant disagreed. It alleged that things done outside the scope of employment-such as an intentional tort like battery-could not be impugned to the employer.

However, it still offered to settle. The plaintiff rejected this amount and took the matter to court where the jury awarded him $200,000.

This Michigan nursing home verdict is surprising because of the following:

  • It is eight times what the defendant offered but a little under half of what the plaintiff demanded;
  • It was largely based off the plaintiff’s claims of long-term disability; and
  • It is more than twenty times what the plaintiff claimed in economic damages.

$300,000 Nursing Home Verdict

Michigan nursing home abuse case.

What facts we can gather from this Michigan nursing home incident make it clear that the resident was clearly abused. However, just how much and by who are rather hard to determine especially because the case short-circuited into a private settlement.

Here’s what we know: the victim was a woman in her early eighties. She was attempting to use the community restroom just outside of the dining room when another resident came in and attacked her.

A nursing home employee also entered right after he did and might have harmed her as well. Unfortunately, the aggressor was suffering from dementia and other mental problems so getting his side of the story proved to be quite difficult.

The woman sued both of them as well as the nursing home itself. She alleged that the two individuals committed intentional torts against her including assault and battery. She also claimed that the nursing home committed negligence through its faulty supervision, hiring, and service. Her complaint sought damages for her bodily injuries, emotional trauma, and medical bills.

Once the matter got to trial though, only the claim against the nursing home survived because she ended her pursuit against the employee and resident. About one month after the trial commenced, they too settled and moved on from the affair.

She received $300,000 from the facility which was apportioned according to the following breakdown:

  • About ten percent of the award was given to satisfy a Medicare lien;
  • One third was given for costs and attorney’s fees; and
  • The rest was given to her for her bodily and other injuries.

$75,000 Nursing Home Settlement

Macomb County, Michigan nursing home abuse case.

This was a different kind of nursing home abuse case than you might ordinarily see in Michigan or anywhere else for that matter. It was different in the form of abuse that the resident suffered and sued for.

What happened was that over the course of several months a third-party employee persuaded an elderly woman living at a care facility to deposit large sums of money into an account owned and managed by the worker.

Then, the employee left the employment of the nursing home leaving the resident to hold the bag and without the money. Interestingly, when she eventually filed her lawsuit in Michigan court, she sued not only that person but also the nursing home.

She argued that the facility was liable because of its deficient screening and supervision of its own workers. She asked for damages for the money she lost and trauma she endured.

This kind of financial exploitation is increasingly common in nursing homes and so is her success in court.

She recovered $75,000 in settlement from the defendant home which correlates to the following points:

  • Her financial losses were around $50,000 so she got less in non-economic damages than is typical in other kinds of nursing home lawsuits; and
  • The case took roughly eight months which is about ten months shorter than the average duration for Michigan nursing home trials.

Michigan Nursing Home Abuse Case Takeaways

If you’re involved in an abuse incident at a Michigan nursing home, then there are a couple of things that you need to focus on in order to protect your legal rights. Remember these takeaways:

  1. It is imperative that you investigate and collect evidence soon because nursing homes will try and say it did not happen or you were not injured to the extent that you claim. You need proof to rebut these charges.
  2. One of the most common claims nursing homes use in Michigan abuse lawsuits is that the employees acted outside the scope of their employment. Thus, they shouldn’t be held liable. To quash this defense, show how the act was in the regular course of their work and that it did not occur away and apart from the usual circumstances of nursing homes.
  3. Many nursing homes are insured but that policy may not apply to acts of intentional abuse by its employees.

Was Your Loved One Abused at a Michigan Nursing Home?

Lawyers at Nursing Home Law News work with residents that have been abused at the hands of nursing homes. We spend our working days making they sure they get the justice they deserve and you get the recovery that you need.

If you call us a call, we can schedule an initial meeting to screen your case and review what recovery might be awaiting you. It’s worth it. You deserve it and we can help.

To learn more about Michigan nursing home lawsuits, please read the following pages:

  • Michigan Nursing Home Fall Cases
  • Michigan Nursing Home Bed Sore Cases
  • Michigan Nursing Home Medical Error Cases
  • Michigan Nursing Home Inadequate Care Cases

For information on Michigan laws and regulations related to nursing homes, look at our page here.

If you are looking for information on a facility in a particular city or a local lawyer, please see pages below:

Client Reviews

Jonathan did a great job helping my family navigate through a lengthy lawsuit involving my grandmother's death in a nursing home. Through every step of the case, Jonathan kept my family informed of the progression of the case. Although our case eventually settled at a mediation, I really was impressed at how well prepared Jonathan was to take the case to trial. Lisa
After I read Jonathan’s Nursing Home Blog, I decided to hire him to look into my wife’s treatment at a local nursing home. Jonathan did a great job explaining the process and the laws that apply to nursing homes. I immediately felt at ease and was glad to have him on my side. Though the lawsuit process was at times frustrating, Jonathan reassured me, particularly at my deposition. I really felt like Jonathan cared about my wife’s best interests, and I think that came across to the lawyers for the nursing home. Eric