Published on:

Appellate Court Orders Retrial In Nursing Home Negligence Case With $29.8M In Punitive Damages

Following an appeal by a nursing home operator based on an excessive verdict, an Appellate Court has ordered a re-trial of the punitive damage aspect of a nursing home negligence case.  The case was originally tried in Warren County Circuit court and a jury awarded $4.1 M in compensatory damages and $29.8 M in punitive damages.

Retrial In Nursing Home Negligence Case The nursing home negligence lawsuit was brought by the daughters of Cheatum Myers, an 88-year-old man who allegedly died prematurely while he was a resident at a nursing home owned by National Healthcare Corporation, a Murfreesboro-based nursing home operator.  The family’s lawsuit involved separate counts for negligence, medical malpractice and wrongful death.

National Healthcare Corporation has 60 days from the entry of the Appellate Court’s decision to file a motion to reconsider with the Tennessee Supreme Court.  National Healthcare Corporation is the 11th largest nursing home operator in the United States and currently houses over 9,000 elderly residents.  Read more about this nursing home negligence lawsuit here.

Punitive Damages

Punitive damages are damages not awarded in order to compensate the plaintiff, but in order to punish or deter the defendant and similar persons from similar behavior that harmed the plaintiff (injured party).  In most jurisdictions, plaintiffs must get permission from the court to pursue a claim for punitive damages.  There is no set limit or absolutely impermissible ratio of punitive damages to compensatory damages, though punitive damages with outrageously high ratios have been reversed by appellate courts.

For more information on nursing homes in Tennessee look here.

Related Nursing Homes Abuse Blog Posts

Juries Sending A Message To Nursing Homes

Big Verdicts Against Nursing Homes

Client Reviews

  • Having worked in the medical field, I appreciated the way that Mr. Rosenfeld and his staff approached my family’s situation. The combination of medical knowledge and legal expertise was indeed the winning combination for our case.
  • While nothing can change the way our mother was treated at a nursing facility, I do feel a sense of vindication that the facility was forced to pay for their treatment. I am certain that they would never have done had my attorneys not held their feet to the fire.
  • I was very nervous about initiating a claim against my mother’s nursing facility, but Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers took care of everything from getting the medical records to going to court. I felt like I had real advocates on my side. That meant a lot to me.
  • After a horrific episode at a nursing home, my sister and I spoke to a number of law firms. No one took the time to answer our questions and explain the legal process like Mr. Rosenfeld. He did a tremendous job on our case and I can see why he’s earned the praise he has from clients and peers.
  • I liked the fact that I could call the office and ask questions about the legal process at anytime. I could tell that my case was in good hands. I think that this was reflected in my father’s settlement was more than I anticipated the case ever being worth.